About the Brooklynite cocktail

The Brooklynite is a classic rum cocktail that dates back to the Prohibition era, when speakeasies relied on bold flavors and clever mixes to disguise the rough edges of bootleg spirits.

The drink is a simple but elegant blend of aged Jamaican rum, lime juice, honey syrup, and Angostura bitters, and it first appeared in mid-20th century cocktail literature, including the Esquire Handbook for Hosts (1949).

This honeyed sour has been called one of the most approachable rum cocktails, balancing depth, sweetness, and spice with refreshing citrus.

It captures a little of New York’s rebellious energy, even though its roots are firmly tied to Caribbean rum.

What Makes the Brooklynite Cocktail Special

The Brooklynite cocktail recipe is rich, aromatic, and balanced — proof that simplicity often makes for the most memorable drinks.

Honey syrup gives it a round, velvety sweetness that pairs beautifully with the funk and spice of Jamaican rum, while lime juice cuts through with brightness.

The dash of Angostura bitters adds depth, weaving in subtle notes of spice and herbs that linger after each sip.

It’s essentially a rum-based take on the honey sour, and it works so well because it highlights the natural character of aged Jamaican rum without overwhelming it.

Spirit Swaps and Food Pairings

Want to make this classic your own?

• Swap Jamaican rum for Barbados rum for a slightly softer, caramel-driven drink.

• Use a split base of rum and bourbon for added warmth.

• Try clover or orange blossom honey to subtly shift the flavor profile.

The Brooklynite pairs perfectly with foods that complement its honey-citrus balance — think roasted chicken, jerk-seasoned pork, or honey-glazed salmon.

On the snack side, it’s excellent with spiced nuts or a sharp cheese plate.

Why the Brooklynite Endures

The Brooklynite is smooth, timeless, and versatile.

It’s a cocktail that feels equally at home in a speakeasy-inspired bar or mixed up for a relaxed evening at home.

With only a few ingredients, it offers sophistication without complication — a true hidden gem of the rum world.